Toggle menu
Welcome to Classic Pins!
5 Commerce Rd - Box 407 - Newtown, CT 06470
866.357.5040
Sign in
or
Register
Compare
Gift
Certificates
Recently
Viewed
Cart
Search
Categories
Olympic Pins
All Olympic Pins
Beijing 2022 Olympic Pins
Tokyo 2020 & 2021 Olympic Pins
Los Angeles 2028 Olympic Pins
PyeongChang 2018 Olympic Pins
Rio de Janeiro 2016 Olympic Pins
Sochi 2014 Olympic Pins
London 2012 Olympic Pins
All London 2012 Olympic Pins
London 2012 Olympics Logo Pins
London 2012 Olympics Mascot Pins
London 2012 Olympics Icon and Landmarks Pins
London 2012 Olympic Event Pins
London 2012 Olympics Oversized Pins
London 2012 Olympics Taxi Pins
London 2012 Olympics Stadium / Venue Pins
London 2012 - USA House Pin Collection
London 2012 Olympics Accessories
Team USA Pins
Vancouver 2010 Olympic Pins
All Vancouver 2010 Olympic Pins
Vancouver 2010 Olympic Logo Pins
Vancouver 2010 Olympic Mascot Pins
Vancouver 2010 Olympic Oversized Pins
Vancouver 2010 Olympic Bridge Pins
Vancouver 2010 Olympic Landmark Pins
Vancouver 2010 Olympic Event Pins
Beijing 2008 Olympic Pins
All Beijing 2008 Olympic Pins
Beijing 2008 Olympics Logo Pins
Beijing 2008 Olympics Mascot Pins
Beijing 2008 Olympics Imported Olympic Pins
Beijing 2008 Olympics Event Pins
Beijing 2008 Olympic Games Information
Torino 2006 Olympic Pins
Athens 2004 Olympic Pins
Salt Lake City 2002 Olympic Pins
Past Olympic Pins
Team USA Five Rings Pins
The Last Olympic Pins from Aminco
Olympic Flags
Olympic Travel Items
MLB
All MLB
MLB Teams
All MLB Teams
Arizona Diamondbacks
Atlanta Braves
Baltimore Orioles
Boston Red Sox
Chicago Cubs
Chicago White Sox
Cincinnati Reds
Cleveland Guardians
Cleveland Indians
Colorado Rockies
Detroit Tigers
Houston Astros
Kansas City Royals
Los Angeles Angels
Los Angeles Dodgers
Milwaukee Brewers
Minnesota Twins
Miami Marlins
New York Yankees
All New York Yankees
Lapel Pins
Earrings I Jewelry I Watches
Lanyards I Bag Tags I Key Chains
Coins I Patches & More
New York Mets
Oakland A's
Philadelphia Phillies
Pittsburgh Pirates
San Diego Padres
San Francisco Giants
Seattle Mariners
St. Louis Cardinals
Tampa Bay Rays
Texas Rangers
Toronto Blue Jays
Washington Nationals
Montreal Expos
World Series
All World Series
2021 World Series & Playoffs
2020 World Series & Playoffs
2019 World Series & Playoffs
2018 World Series & Playoffs
2017 World Series & Playoffs
2016 World Series
2015 World Series
2014 World Series
2013 World Series
2012 World Series
2011 World Series
2010 World Series
2009 World Series
2008 World Series
2007 World Series
2006 World Series
2005 World Series
2004 World Series
2003 World Series
2002 World Series
2000 World Series
Past World Series Pins
World Series History Pin Collection
All World Series History Pin Collection
World Series History Collection By Release
MLB All Star Games
All MLB All Star Games
2022 MLB All-Star Game
2021 MLB All-Star Game
2020 MLB All-Star Game
2019 MLB All-Star Game
2018 MLB All-Star Game
2017 MLB All-Star Game
2016 MLB All-Star Game
2015 MLB All-Star Game
2014 MLB All Star Game
2013 MLB All-Star Game
2012 MLB All Star Game
2011 MLB All Star Game
2010 MLB All Star Game
2009 MLB All Star Game
2008 MLB All Star Game
2006 MLB All Star Game
2002 MLB All Star Game
2001 MLB All-Star Game
2000 MLB All Star Game
1999 MLB All Star Game
MLB Hall of Fame
MLB Milestones
World Series Dynasty Teams
MLB Stadium Pins
MLB Jewelry & Accessories
All MLB Jewelry & Accessories
MLB Earrings
MLB Luggage Tags
MLB Lanyards
MLB Key Chains
MLB Necklaces
MLB Money Clips
MLB Sunglasses
MLB Travel Locks
MLB Bracelets & Wristbands
MLB Patches
MLB Magnets
MLB Coins
MLB Patches
All MLB Patches
MLB Team Patches
MLB Special Event Patches
MLB Disney
MLB Player Pins
All MLB Player Pins
Aaron Judge
Albert Pujols
Alex Rodriguez
Alfonso Soriano
Barry Bonds
Bob Gibson
Bryce Harper
Carlos Beltan
David Ortiz
David Wright
Derek Jeter
Derek Jeter Retirement Coin Collection
Eddie Mathews
Ernie Banks
Frank Robinson
Gary Sheffield
Hideki Matsui
Ichiro Suzuki
Jackie Robinson
Jason Giambi
Jim Palmer
Jim Thome
Joe DiMaggio
Johnny Bench
Kazuhiro Sasaki
Larry Doby
Madison Bumgarner
Marco Scutaro
Mark McGwire
Mark Teixeira
Masahiro Tanaka
Mike Piazza
Nolan Ryan
Paul Konerko
Paul Molitor
Pete Rose
Randy Johnson
Reggie Jackson
Robinson Cano
Roger Clemens
Stan Musial
Ted Williams
Willie Stargell
Yogi Berra Pins
World Baseball Classic
All World Baseball Classic
2013 WBC
2009 WBC
2006 WBC
MLB Framed Pin Sets
MLB Vintage Logo Pins
NFL
All NFL
NFL Teams
All NFL Teams
Arizona Cardinals
Atlanta Falcons
Baltimore Ravens
Buffalo Bills
Carolina Panthers
Chicago Bears
Cincinnati Bengals
Cleveland Browns
Dallas Cowboys
Denver Broncos
Detroit Lions
Green Bay Packers
Houston Texans
Indianapolis Colts
Jacksonville Jaguars
Kansas City Chiefs
Los Angeles Chargers
Los Angeles Rams
Miami Dolphins
Minnesota Vikings
New England Patriots
New Orleans Saints
New York Giants
New York Jets
Oakland Raiders
Philadelphia Eagles
Pittsburgh Steelers
San Francisco 49ers
Seattle Seahawks
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Tennessee Titans
Washington Commanders
Washington Redskins
Super Bowls
All Super Bowls
Super Bowl LVI (56)
Super Bowl LV (55)
Super Bowl LIV (54)
Super Bowl LIII (53)
Super Bowl LII (52)
Super Bowl LI (51)
Super Bowl L (50)
Super Bowl XLIX (49)
Super Bowl XVLIII (48)
Super Bowl XLVII (47)
Super Bowl XLVI (46)
Super Bowl XLV (45)
Super Bowl XLIV (44)
Super Bowl XLII (42)
Super Bowl XLIII (43)
Super Bowl XLI (41)
Super Bowl XL (40)
Super Bowl XXXIX (39)
Super Bowl XXXVIII (38)
Super Bowl XXXVII (37)
Super Bowl XXXVI (36)
Super Bowl XXXV (35)
Super Bowl XXXIV (34)
Super Bowl XXXIII (33)
Super Bowl XXXII (32)
Super Bowl XXXI (31)
Super Bowl XXX (30)
Super Bowl XXIX (29)
Super Bowl XXVIII (28)
Super Bowl XXVII (27)
Super Bowl XXVI (26)
Super Bowl XXV (25)
Super Bowl XXIV (24)
Super Bowl XXIII (23)
Super Bowl XXII (22)
Super Bowl XXI (21)
Super Bowl XX (20)
Super Bowl XIX (19)
Super Bowl XVIII (18)
Super Bowl XVII (17)
Super Bowl XVI (16)
Super Bowl XV (15)
Super Bowl XIV (14)
Super Bowl XIII (13)
Super Bowl XII (12)
Super Bowl XI (11)
Super Bowl X (10)
Super Bowl IX (9)
Super Bowl VIII (8)
Super Bowl VII (7)
Super Bowl VI (6)
Super Bowl V (5)
Super Bowl IV (4)
Super Bowl III (3)
Super Bowl II (2)
Super Bowl I (1)
Super Bowl Oversized Pins
NFL Jewelry & Accessories
All NFL Jewelry & Accessories
NFL Earrings
NFL Luggage Tags
NFL Lanyards
NFL Necklaces
NFL Key Chains
NFL Money Clips
NFL Bracelets & Wristbands
NFL Sunglasses
NFL Travel Locks
NFL Magnets
NFL Coins
Super Bowl Dynasty Teams
NFL Player Pins
NFL Framed Pin Sets
NHL
All NHL
NHL Teams
All NHL Teams
Anaheim Ducks
Arizona Coyotes
Atlanta Thrashers
Boston Bruins
Buffalo Sabres
Calgary Flames
Carolina Hurricanes
Chicago Blackhawks
Colorado Avalanche
Columbus Blue Jackets
Dallas Stars
Detroit Red Wings
Edmonton Oilers
Florida Panthers
Los Angeles Kings
Minnesota Wild
Montreal Canadiens
Nashville Predators
New Jersey Devils
New York Islanders
New York Rangers
Ottawa Senators
Philadelphia Flyers
Pittsburgh Penguins
San Jose Sharks
Seattle Kraken
St. Louis Blues
Tampa Bay Lightning
Toronto Maple Leafs
Vancouver Canucks
Vegas Golden Knights
Washington Capitals
Winnipeg Jets
Hartford Whalers
Stanley Cup
All Stanley Cup
2022 Stanley Cup
2021 Stanley Cup
2020 Stanley Cup /Playoffs
2019 Stanley Cup / Playoffs
2018 Stanley Cup
2017 Stanley Cup
2016 Stanley Cup
2015 Stanley Cup
2014 Stanley Cup
2013 Stanley Cup
2012 Stanley Cup
2011 Stanley Cup
2009 Stanley Cup
2008 Stanley Cup
2007 Stanley Cup
2004 Stanley Cup
2002 Stanley Cup
NHL Winter Classic Games
World Cup of Hockey
NHL Jewelry & Accessories
All NHL Jewelry & Accessories
NHL Earrings
NHL Lanyards
NHL Luggage Tags
NHL Key Chains
NHL Money Clips
NHL Necklaces
NHL Bracelets & Wristbands
NHL All Star Games
NHL Framed Pin Sets
NBA
All NBA
NBA Teams
All NBA Teams
Atlanta Hawks
Boston Celtics
Brooklyn Nets
Charlotte Hornets
Chicago Bulls
Cleveland Cavaliers
Dallas Mavericks
Denver Nuggets
Detroit Pistons
Golden State Warriors
Houston Rockets
Indiana Pacers
Los Angeles Clippers
Los Angeles Lakers
Memphis Grizzlies
Miami Heat
Milwaukee Bucks
Minnesota Timberwolves
New Jersey Nets
New Orleans Hornets
New Orleans Pelicans
New York Knicks
Oklahoma City Thunder
Orlando Magic
Philadelphia 76ers
Phoenix Suns
Portland Trail Blazers
Sacramento Kings
San Antonio Spurs
Toronto Raptors
Utah Jazz
Washington Wizards
NBA Finals and Playoffs
All NBA Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2022 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2021 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2020 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2019 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2018 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2017 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2016 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2015 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2014 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2013 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2012 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2011 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2010 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2009 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2008 Finals and Playoffs
NBA 2007 Finals and Playoffs
NBA Previous Finals and Playoffs (Pre-2007)
NBA Jewelry & Accessories
All NBA Jewelry & Accessories
NBA Earrings
NBA Lanyards
NBA Luggage Tags
NBA Key Chains
NBA Money Clips
NBA Necklaces
NBA Bracelets & Wristbands
NBA Vintage Pins
NBA Players
NBA All Star Games
NBA Framed Pin Sets
WNBA
All WNBA
Atlanta Dream
Charlotte Sting
Chicago Sky
Cleveland Rockers
Connecticut Sun
Dallas Wings
Detroit Shock
Houston Comets
Indiana Fever
Los Angeles Sparks
Minnesota Lynx
New York Liberty
Orlando Miracle
Phoenix Mercury
Portland Fire
Sacramento Monarchs
San Antonio Silver Stars
Seattle Storm
Tulsa Shock
Washington Mystics
NCAA
All NCAA
NCAA Schools
All NCAA Schools
Air Force Academy
Alabama
Arizona
Arizona State
Arkansas
Army
Auburn
Baylor
Boise State
Boston College
Brigham Young
Cal Berkeley
Central Florida
Central Michigan
Cincinnati
Clemson
Colorado
Connecticut
Duke
Drexel
East Carolina
Emporia State
Florida
Florida State
Fresno State
Georgia
Georgia Southern
Georgia Tech
Gonzaga
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Iowa State
Kansas
Kansas State
Kentucky
LaSalle
Louisville
LSU
Marquette
Marshall
Maryland
Memphis
Miami
Miami of Ohio
Michigan
Michigan State
Minnesota
Mississippi
Mississippi State
Missouri
Missouri State
Missouri Western State
Montana
Navy Academy
Nebraska
North Carolina
North Carolina State
North Dakota
North Dakota State
Northwestern
Notre Dame
Ohio State
Oklahoma
Oklahoma State
Oregon
Oregon State
Pennsylvania
Penn State
Pittsburgh
Purdue
San Diego State
South Carolina
South Dakota State
South Florida
Southern Illinois
Southern Mississippi
Southern Methodist
Stanford
St. Louis University
Syracuse
Temple
Tennessee
Tennessee Lady Vols
Texas
Texas Arlington
Texas A&M
Texas At El Paso
Texas Christian
Texas San Antonio
Texas State
Texas Tech
UCLA
UNI
UNLV
USC
Utah
Utah State
Utah Valley
Vanderbilt
Villanova
Virginia
Virginia Tech
Washington
Washington State
West Chester
Western Michigan
West Virginia
Wichita State
Wisconsin
Wyoming
Xavier
Rose Bowl 2022 Centennial
Final Four & Frozen Four
All Final Four & Frozen Four
2022 Final Four
2021 Final Four / Frozen Four
2020 Final Four / Frozen Four
2019 Final Four / Frozen Four
2018 Final Four / Frozen Four
2017 Final Four / Frozen Four
2016 Final Four / Frozen Four
2015 Final Four l Frozen Four
2014 Final Four | Frozen Four
2013 Final Four | Frozen Four
2012 Final Four | Frozen Four
2011 Final Four | Frozen Four
2010 Final Four
2009 Final Four
2008 Final Four
2006 Final Four
2005 Final Four
2004 Final Four
2003 Final Four
Bowl Games
All Bowl Games
2021-2022 Bowl Games
2020 - 2021 Bowl Games
2019-2020 Bowl Games
2018-2019 Bowl Games
2017-2018 Bowl Games
2017-1016 Bowl Games
2016 - 2015 Bowl Games
2015 - 2014 Bowl Games
2014 Bowl Games
2013 Bowl Games
2012 Bowl Games
2011 Bowl Games
2010 Bowl Games
2009 Bowl Games
2008 Bowl Games
2007 Bowl Games
2006 Bowl Games
2005 Bowl Games
2004 Bowl Games
2003 Bowl Games
College World Series
NCAA Jewelry & Accessories
All NCAA Jewelry & Accessories
NCAA Earrings
NCAA Lanyards
NCAA Luggage Tags
NCAA Key Chains
NCAA Money Clips
NCAA Necklaces
NCAA Travel Locks
NCAA Sunglasses
NCAA Magnets
NCAA Bracelets & Wristbands
NCAA Coins
NASCAR
Soccer
All Soccer
MLS Soccer
All MLS Soccer
Atanta FC
Austin FC
Charlotte Football Club
Chicago Fire
Cincinnati FC
Colorado Rapids
Columbus Crew
D.C. United
FC Dallas
Houston Dynamo
Impact Montreal
Los Angeles FC
Los Angeles Galaxy
Miami FC
Minnesota United
Nashville FC
New England Revolution
New York City FC
New York Red Bulls
Orlando City
Philadelphia Union
Portland Timbers
Real Salt Lake
San Jose Earthquakes
Seattle Sounders
Sporting Kansas City
Toronto FC
Vancouver Whitecaps
USA Soccer
European / World Soccer
2018 FIFA World Cup
2014 FIFA World Cup
Tennis Pins
Horse Racing
All Horse Racing
Kentucky Derby
All Kentucky Derby
2022 Kentucky Derby 148
2021 Kentucky Derby 147
2020 Kentucky Derby 146
2019 Kentucky Derby 145
2018 Kentucky Derby 144
Justify 2018 Triple Crown
2017 Kentucky Derby 143
2016 Kentucky Derby 142
2015 Kentucky Derby 141
Kentucky Derby Pins
Kentucky Derby Coins
Horse Racing Pins
Saratoga
Seabiscuit Pins
Horse Racing Posters
Horse Racing Misc. Items
UFC
Disney Pins
All Disney Pins
Mickey Mouse Pins
Princess Pins
Tinkerbell Pins
Theme Park Pins
MLB Disney
Other Disney Pins
Military Items
All Military Items
Army
Navy
Air Force
Marines
Coast Guard
Patriotic Pins
All Patriotic Pins
September 11 Pins
Flag Pins
Ribbon/Awareness Pins
Patriotic Flags
Misc. Patriotic Items
Political Party Pins
Animal Pins
All Animal Pins
Wildlife Pins & Magnets
Dog Pins
Holiday Pins
All Holiday Pins
Easter
Valentine's
Christmas
Religious Jewelry
Destination Pins
All Destination Pins
City Pins
Parks Pins
State Pins
Stamp Pins
All Stamp Pins
Sports Stamp Pins
Holiday Stamp Pins
Entertainment Stamp Pins
States Stamp Pins
Other Stamp Pins
Pin Bags & Displays
All Pin Bags & Displays
Lapel Pin Bags
Lapel Pin Displays
Lapel Pin Backs - Clutches
Framed Pin Sets
Classic Limiteds
All Classic Limiteds
MLB Limited Pins
NFL Limited Pins
NBA Limited Pins
NHL Limited Pins
Olympic Limited Pins
Other Limited Pins
Other Pins & Jewelry
All Other Pins & Jewelry
Elvis Presley Collectibles
Betty Boop Collectibles
Coca Cola Pins
Rockettes Pins
Sandy Hook School Fundraiser Pins
Fashion Jewelry
Misc. Pins
League Logo Pins
Custom Lapel Pins
Track Your Order
Lapel Pins
Earrings
Lanyards
Custom Pins
Luggage Tags
Key Chains
Money Clips
Necklaces
Same Day Ship
Same Day Ship
Newsletter
Classic Limiteds
Help Desk
Help Desk
About Us
Terms and Conditions
Shipping & Returns
Privacy Policy
Blog
RSS
Gift Certificates
Sign in
Register
Search
Gary Sheffield
Home
MLB
MLB Player Pins
Gary Sheffield
Gary Sheffield
Clear All
There are no products listed under this category.
OK
